Heart and Mind
The writer, Dr Hasnain Gulamali Walji (Texas, USA), is the Head of the Khoja Heritage Project of The World Federation of KSIMC. A lifelong educator and historian, he has dedicated over three decades to documenting the rich, socio-religious journey of the Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri community. His landmark documentary, The Khojas – A Journey of Faith, traces this evolution across 600 years. Over the past 30 years he had been collecting care Gujarati and Khoji history books housed at the Mulla Asghar Memorial Library in Toronto, which he co-founded with Raza-Aly Hiridjee.
Serving for almost half a century, he had been the former Secretary General, Vice President, and President of The World Federation. Professionally, he is a nutritionist and has also authored 26 books on naturopathic medicine, translated into several languages. As Executive Director of the United Global Initiative and a Trustee of the Jaffer Family Foundation, he leads the CodeGirls project, which empowers underprivileged girls to pursue technology careers. He has also been instrumental in facilitating the ‘Ashura at Harvard’ study track at Harvard Divinity School, promoting academic discourse on Shi’ism through the fully funded the JafferFamily Foundation.
Reason walks into a café – early, polished, and painfully punctual.
Orders black coffee. No sugar. No joy either.
Heart shows up fashionably late, humming a tune no one remembers.
Orders chai. Two spoons of nostalgia, and just a hint of rebellion.
Reason opens a spreadsheet. Heart opens its chest.
Reason says, “We must optimise feelings.”
Heart replies, “We must feel them first.”
The barista’s confused. Probably thinks it’s a philosophy podcast.
Reason lists facts, graphs, and global GDP data.
Heart gestures to the rain outside. “That,” it says, “is divine handwriting.”
Reason rolls its eyes. “You’re hopeless.”
Heart shrugs. “At least I’m alive.”
And somewhere in a corner, Iqbal sips his tea, smiling the way only poets do – the smile of someone who saw this argument coming a hundred years ago.
Iqbal’s poem Aqal-o-Dil – “Reason and Heart”, is basically that café conversation, written before cafés existed. Long before TED Talks and neuroscience, he turned our daily internal brawl into verse.
Reason, precise like an engineer. Heart, chaotic like a Sufi.
And Iqbal? The referee- amused, not alarmed.
When Reason Took the Mic
Reason begins, of course. It always does.
“Aql ne aik din yeh dil se kaha –
Bhoole bhatke ki rehnuma hoon main.”
Reason said to the Heart: I am the guide for the lost.
Classic Reason. Always auditioning for sainthood.
“Hoon zameen par, guzar falak pe mera –
Dekh tu kis qadar rasa hoon main.”
I walk the earth and touch the skies; behold my reach!
If Reason had a LinkedIn profile, it would say:
“World-class problem solver. Data-driven visionary. Endorsed by Einstein.”
It’s convinced it runs the universe.
But the Heart has been quietly waiting- the kind of waiting only patience and pain can teach.
The Heart Responds (and Wins Without Trying)
Heart doesn’t need an audience.
It needs silence.
“Dil ne kaha ke nahi, yeh sab kuch hai fareb-e-nazar.”
Heart said: All this is illusion – a trick of the eyes.
You can hear the sigh behind that line.
Reason builds telescopes. Heart closes its eyes – and sees deeper.
“Tu hai samundar, mein hoon woh leher –
Jo teri god mein bas jaati hai.”
You are the sea, and I – the wave that rests in your lap.
Reason counts the drops; Heart becomes the ocean.
Then comes the most delicious jab:
“Ilm ne mujh se kaha, ishq hai deewana pan –
Ishq ne mujh se kaha, ilm hai takhmin-o-zan.”
Knowledge told me: Love is madness.
Love replied: Knowledge is mere guesswork.
And there it is.
The world’s shortest roast.
Delivered by Love. Written by Iqbal. Endorsed by eternity.
Iqbal’s Whisper Across Time
Iqbal wasn’t writing for scholars; he was writing for sleepers.
Born in 1877 in Sialkot, when the East had forgotten its pulse,
he came along humming Rumi’s rhythm in Nietzsche’s vocabulary.
He studied in Lahore, Cambridge, and Munich – a triple degree in wisdom, philosophy, and the art of annoying colonial intellectuals. He mastered European thought, then told Europe what it forgot: Brains can build, but hearts create.
For Iqbal, Reason was the engine. Heart was the spark.
And without the spark, even the best machinery just hums pointlessly.
“Aql go aastaan se door nahin –
Is ki taqdeer mein huzoor nahin.”
Though Reason stands close to the threshold of Truth,
it is not destined to behold the Divine.
Reason, in short, is brilliant – and perpetually friend-zoned by Truth.
Why It Still Matters
Fast forward to now.
AI writes poetry. Humans write apologies.
We’ve made machines smarter – and ourselves more mechanical.We know our sleep cycles, step counts, and stress levels –
but not what keeps us awake, restless, and aching.Reason is winning – and humanity is losing.
Iqbal warned us. He saw a civilisation becoming clever but not kind.
He knew the apocalypse wouldn’t come from fire – it would come from too much logic and too little love.“Aql hai mahw-e-tamasha-e-lab-e-bam abhi –
Ishq sar-e-bam hai, muntazir-e-subh-e-wisaal.”
Reason still watches from the balcony of thought;
Love waits on the rooftop for dawn – for union.One stares. The other feels.
One observes life. The other lives it.
From Sialkot to Silicon Valley
Iqbal’s question is timeless:
What happens when the lamp of intellect burns but the oil of love runs dry?
Look around.
We’ve got Wi-Fi, but no connection.
Followers, but no faith.
Data, but no direction.
Reason gives us efficiency. Heart gives us empathy.
One gets us to Mars. The other gets us home.
Reason is Google Maps.
Heart is the driver who ignores it — and finds beauty in getting lost.
So the next time your mind and heart start arguing at 3 a.m.,
don’t try to shut them up. Pour them both a cup of tea.
Let Reason explain.
Let Heart interrupt.
Let Iqbal listen — and smile.
Because somewhere in between you’ll find the only truth that ever mattered: thinking makes you clever, but feeling makes you human.
More from this Writer
Latest posts
- Fear Allah, not people´s judgement
Fear Allah, not people´s judgement by Alhajj Khalil Mohammed Hassan Champsi Sometimes, the way others see us quietly begins to shape the way we live. Their gaze becomes a mirror in which we measure ourselves; their perceptions become questions we carry; their judgements become shadows over choices that were once our own. - A Garden Without End
A Garden Without End Review of Chapter 23 of Bihar Al-Anwaar, Volume 8 Author – The Allama Muhammad Baqir Al Majlisi Chapter 23 of Volume 8 of Bihar Al-Anwaar – the encyclopaedic hadith compendium compiled by the Safavid-era scholar Allama Muhammad Baqir al-Majlisi – is entitled “The Paradise and Its Bounties, and Allah Sustaining Us and the Rest of the Believers, Its Houries, Its Castles, Its Joys and Its Cheerfulness.” Spanning roughly one hundred and eighty pages (pp. 106–285), it sits in the volume between the harrowing chapter on the Bridge over Hell and the chapter on the Fire itself, and it functions as a deliberate counterweight: where the preceding chapters describe terror, this one unfolds an almost luxuriant catalogue of delight. Reading it straight through is a peculiar experience – less a sustained argument than a long, liturgical inventory of a world the believer is invited to imagine as already in existence. This review summarises the chapter’s main themes and offers a few observations on its literary and theological texture. - Marhum (Maalim) Ibrahim Husseinali Nathoo
Marhum (Maalim) Ibrahim Husseinali Nathoo 1942-2024 The Khoja Shia Ithna-Asheri Jamaat of Dar es Salaam mourns the loss of Ibrahim Husseinali Nathoo, who passed away on 23rd October 2024. Ibrahim bhai was a true pillar of our community, a dedicated teacher, and an inspiring example of humility, commitment, and selfless service. Born on 23rd November 1942 in Zanzibar, Ibrahim bhai devoted his life to the service of others. His journey of community service began early and spanned decades, touching countless lives. He served as a teacher and mentor at Husayni Madrasah, where he shaped the minds and souls of multiple generations, always with a kind smile and a humble spirit. His commitment went beyond teaching; he was a guardian, a guide, and a fatherly figure to all who passed through the Madrasah doors.
Writers Panel | A Simple Thought | Obituaries | Ziarat Ashura | Islamic Calendar | Facebook | Instagram
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.